The Terrorist Attacks - Commentaries and Sources

last update: February 4, 2002

A Hard Lesson...

Click to read the famous "Patton Speech"

From the San Diego Union-Tribune, September  13, 2001

Preparation

The New Air Force Song

"Strangers on my Plane" - styled by Frank

Bumper sticker spotted coming up Interstate 35 in late November:

IT'S GOD'S RESPONSIBILITY TO FORGIVE BIN LADEN...
IT'S OUR RESPONSIBILITY TO ARRANGE THE MEETING...!
United States Marines


2002 Reports

Dear Family & Friends, I hope you got a feel for what combat is like in a Navy F-14 from a previous email of mine. Here's one from a US Navy F-18 Pilot. It brings the missions up close and personal. Here is his story....

Thought y'all might get a kick out of a recent experience of mine. I'll chop this for an Approach Magazine article. I'm thinking the parts about the hot Air Force chicks is probably gonna have to be excluded for "political correctness". I'll leave in all the trash talkin' though.

In case anyone asks, flying around in an F 18 without a canopy is bad for the skin. Twenty-thousand feet over Afghanistan in an open air McDonnell Douglas Cabriolet is just a bad, bad place. Air's real dry up there. That and the wind chill of course. 0130 launch. Fifth and final planned tanker rendezvous. (25K MSL guessing 280-285 knots.) Had 13.0 fuel onboard but wanted to run my wingman back through because he only had 10.0 or so with an hour and a half to recovery. Sun was not up (0600) but it was bright enough. My goggles and goggle bracket were both stowed. Tanker had finished consolidating a half hour before and had four receivers (including myself) immediately afterwards. I was the fifth guy to tank. The boom operator recycled the hose between me and number four (dash two of the oncoming marine section). The boom operator called "clear" before I tanked. Tanking appeared normal to me. Air was smooth.

The Hose cut loose and I pulled the power back and picked up the nose in order to try and "ride the wave." The Refueling probe did not feel too much stress based on vibrations I felt in the cockpit. The Hose separated about seven feet forward of the basket. KC10 take-up reel on the refueling hose didn't do it's job. It didn't take up the slack. After some wailing and flailing The KC10 and I disconnected but I still had part of the it with me, the basket and seven feet of hose. The hose had a ten pound fitting on it that was quickly revealed when the wind stripped off the rubber sheath from the hose. Once revealed it proceeded to beating the living s**t out of my airplane.

"This is gonna be bad, this is gonna be real bad," I thought. I was right. After twenty sufficiently violent whacks the canopy gave up the ghost. I never thought about what a shattering canopy would sound like. Up until then of course. I figured since it's made of plastic it shouldn't sound like glass. Wrong. Sounded just like when you go flying through a plate glass window. Of course all the glass went out vice in. Cockpit went from eight grand to ambient in about a heartbeat. Which was a pretty small unit of time right then.

Don't know exactly where the KC10 went. Last I saw him he was turning for the South west, spewing gas in the air and spewing words over the radio. "Bossman" had no time for little 'ole me. One of his Air Force brethren was experiencing discomfort. Had to yell at him to get his attention. At first (before I put the top down) I thought I could make it home. "Okay, it's 650 NM away, I got 13.5....probably have to go pretty slow and kinda low. And that hunk o' s**t on my nose can't be doing much for my gas mileage. This should warrant a ready deck at the Carrier. Yeah one or two passes before they have to barricade me. And I ain't boltered yet so..."

Descended about three thousand feet and decelerated to about 260 by the time the canopy blew. Then the glass shattered. "Okay, Jacobabad it is. My boarding rate at a 10,000 foot airstrip is even better." Went down to about nineteen K and put out the speedbrake. Fitting was still beating up the jet while passing through 240 knots. At about 230 the beatings stopped and I started down, maintaining airspeed. Flight controls and engines appeared fine. Ball was a little out of center but that was it. Didn't have to turn to put JBAD on the nose. It was straight ahead. Nav system told me it was 260 NM away. My body told me it was pretty damn cold up there.

The KC10 remains were still trying to get at my head so I started descending and decelerating (opposing states so I'm not sure I did either one that efficiently). Leveled off at twelve thousand. I stopped getting beat up, the fitting just hung in the slipstream by my canopy bow, at 230 knots. So there I was...Eight thousand feet above Afghanistan at 230 knots. "You know, If a guy really wanted to get shot by a MANPAD missile he'd fly a profile a lot like what I'm doing right now." Oh well. It's at times like this when you just make a decision and go with it. If you pull it off then it was, "...outstanding airmanship and in keeping with the highest tradition of the United States Naval Service..." If you don't pull it off, if you get bagged, well...maybe they'll name a safety award or the new Base Gym after you. Managed to grab the piss bag that was flying around the cockpit and stuff it in my helmet bag. While stuffing other things away the In-flight Pack was ripped out of my hands. It went over the side in a flash. "Scotty's gonna hate that." Inlet temp read 3.

Buffeting while hunkered down behind the glare shield wasn't that bad. My wingman was still with me through all this. Because of some late tankers and shuffling to get guys that were using our tanker to go further north he only had 10K in gas so he definitely wasn't gonna make it back. Well, not definitely, he could still tank after all. But because of how I had to sit in the cockpit to minimize the wind blast I needed him to watch over me. I was pretty much hunkered down for the ride at this point. Seat lowered, visor down, cockpit heat up full and hunched over staring at one of the TV screens in the cockpit. It's weird the thoughts that come to you during times like this. "You know sitting this close to the screen is bad for my eyes." Had to snicker over that one.

I could look right and left and see the Afghanistan and then the Pakistan scenery slowly drifting by. Too slowly. On the descent the airplane's computer was displaying how long it would take me to get to the divert given my decelerating airspeed. "Okay, 20 minutes not bad I can do that no problem...oh thirty minutes now. Okay piece of cake... Forty!? S**t." Settled out at forty eight. In the end I didn't really look outside much. Just peeked over the dashboard every couple of minutes to make sure the velocity vector was on top of the upcoming ridgelines. This part of the world is not pretty by the way.

Once everyone realized the seriousness of the situation they started to talk to me. The AWACS switched me over to the E2 in charge of the South. They started relaying stuff I needed to tell the Boat. The parts the jet would need in order to make a flight back out again. The fact that my wingman was going to make the 0900 recovery vice the 0730, stuff like that. "The Boat wants to know how badly the canopy is cracked." I couldn't believe that one. I thought he would have heard all the wind in the cockpit and known. "It's not cracked, it's gone. I'm flying a convertible."

Apparently that line made it through all the nets loud and clear. The next day I was talking with the CSAR guys in Jbad and they said they got spun up when the read that on chat. (It's all real time chat nowadays.) What did not get through was the driver of the convertible. I know the E2 guy knew who I was (the conversation by the end had degenerated to callsigns. Gretzky and Duck. Not professional but somewhat comforting) but somehow the Boat was waiting for me to return at 0900 vice my wingman. All this technology...

As far as the cockpit was concerned there were two different and distinct regions. From my knees down I was toasty and warm. "This little piggy" was getting sweaty in fact. Then the chilly zone above that. The wind was swirling around pretty good and I was trying to grab all the paper and shove it into my helmet bag. Only lost one bit of classified stuff. Not too bad all things considered. After twenty minutes I started getting the shakes; after thirty they were fully developed. I tried to stuff my whole body down by the rudder pedals with limited success. Kept my hands warm though. Thank God for auto pilot.

About this time my wingman came up and said, "Hey can you reach out and grab that thing, pull it in?" I looked over at him (not that he could see me) with a look of shock. Stick my arm out into that wind, get my arm blasted back and thrashed on the glass shards sticking up everywhere? "Have you lost your mind?!" "Oh yeah, guess it's kinda windy. Sorry." Like I said, it's strange the thoughts you have sometime. My wingman and I talked about the airfield. Frequencies, layout, the fact that the locals like to shoot at planes landing there. You know, just normal airport talk. We talked about landing on a runway, something neither of us had done for three months. And we dumped fuel to lighten the load. We both were carrying two thousand pounds of unexpended ordnance so the Air Force guys were gonna love us. Lastly we dropped the landing gear in close formation and compared airspeed and AOA to make sure the KC10 hadn't damaged my AOA and airspeed probes as well.

I had him land first because I thought the hose might drag on the ground and get rolled up on by the nose wheel. After that who knew what would happen. Dumped down to 3.0 each. Airspeed and AOA checked accomplished at 170 and 150 knots. Appeared fine. Approach was initiated from 5k AGL when the threshold was ten degrees down. Started to slow the descent at about five hundred feet. Landed on speed at the nine board. Don't remember seeing a VASI or anything. Airfield diagram on approach plate doesn't show any landing aids. The plane flew fine with all that junk on it. Just had to use the rudder pedals, which is kind of an emergency procedure for a Hornet pilot. When I slowed to on speed I got the "sunroof effect" pretty bad. You know when you're zorching down the road and you open the sunroof but leave all the other windows up? That vibration you get until you crack another window? Well, I got kind of an advanced case of that during my Space Shuttle descent to final.

We both rolled out fine. Well, maybe not fine. We had to use all ten thousand feet and both had smoking brakes. (Our brakes hadn't been used like that in a while. On the Boat the wire brings you to a gentle stop without them, of course.) The emergency crews were waiting for us. And they were pointing and gawking as would be appropriate for a situation such as this. Couple of natives looked on in a disinterested matter. Of course I had to do a flight physical after all this. Had to make sure I wasn't on drugs before I launched on my six hour mission into Afghanistan.

The facilities in Jacobabad ain't that bad. I'm here to tell you we are number one in tent technology. Our tents kick ass. They have AC and everything. Since it's an Air Force base they got all the best entertainment. Drew Carry and Joan Jett had been there already. Shania Twain was supposedly coming too (broke my heart, if only I'd had better timing...). And of course the Toga Party on Saturday. Can't forget that. Yeah, it's kinda like the Boat. Except for the booze and the Toga Parties. Other than that it's just like the Boat. Other random observations: Air Force has all the good buildings. Marines are on the outskirts, again. The boys from the 101st are spoiling for a fight. Hate coming in behind the Marines all the time. Dust over everything. Lots of people there that don't look like they are in the normal military. I don't care what any psychology major would say about it, it's just cool carrying a gun everywhere. MREs (Meals Ready to Eat) are not too bad. Could see how people would get sick of them though. Tent city was a little slice of American suburbia right in rural Pakistan. Only Air Force base I've ever been on that didn't have any hot chicks. Of course I was only there for 24 hours.

The place is a FOD (Foreign Object Damage) nightmare. The maintainers showed up about four hours after I did. After the appropriate amount of gawking they got to work and fixed it well enough for the Return To the Boat in under four hours. Nice job all around. By then the basket and hose were removed, the canopy had been replaced and the LEX repaired with 300 mile an hour tape. ("Americans. Can Do Easy.") Three of the guys showed up and then disappeared with two big boxes of geedunk. They were on a booze hunt. They succeeded. The Air Force settled all the maintainers into two spare tents and they had a grand 'ole time. The next morning I took off low and fast at sunrise. Low and fast was due to the locals and the guns, of course. Not because it was fun.

I checked in and the E2 said, "It's good to hear your voice again." The RTB was uneventful right up until the end. A PTS shaft died and subsequently one of my Hydraulic systems gave up the ghost when I dropped the gear. I got a couple of spurious flight control cautions but didn't really give it much thought as I was working the landing. As I started the approach turn the nose started to wander and I got another caution tone. I lost one aileron, one rudder and half a horizontal stab. I hit the reset button and I think everything cleared. Then I saw the Hydraulic Cautions come up. Hitting the reset button suddenly went from normal response on short final to a big mistake. When the aileron failed again I realized I sorta needed to get aboard the first time. "Man, first I miss Shania and now this. This is just not my week."

I got it aboard because the Hornet is a fantastic jet. I got a Fair grade for the pass because I'm not very smooth when I'm rattled. I pretty much assumed I was in trouble throughout all this. A canopy has got to cost 70 or 80 grand. Depending on how much repairing the windscreen and the airframe were...it could cost over 200 grand. Which would mean a Class B mishap. Which would mean I was screwed, Again. Thinking all this and then seeing the CO waiting for me when I landed made my heart sink. But that was not the reason he was there. The decision was made somewhere to make a big deal about this in a good way. Just like that...dirtbag to hero. Funny.

Turned over bodily fluids to VFA-147 Safety Officer. This isn't the first thing that's happened to me out here you know. We're flying the s**t out of these jets and it's starting to show. I had to come back from the box with an engine shut down a week or two before. I'm starting to feel like that LT that keeps getting hosed in "The Bridges of Toko Ri." I got my letter in after all. I'm getting too short for this s**t. Oh well, statistically speaking the rest of cruise should be smooth sailing. What are the odds something like this will happen again? (I love planting the seeds of irony.)

It's me again... The Admiral on the Carrier in the movie Bridges at Toko Ri asked at the end of the movie, "Where do we get such men?" The answer is "Any Bar"

Here's a great letter from a young TOMCAT pilot to his family describing life on USS Theodore Roosevelt in support of operations in Afghanistan:

Subject: Beer Day #3 and a NYFD, Ladder 37 request

Belated Merry Christmas and Happy New Year everbody- Sorry to take so long to get you this update but I've been really, really busy procrastinating.

Ship's TV had the NFL playoffs on last weekend live! Loved the small taste of home that comes with watching football, I just don't dig the late hour that the games come on over here. Rolling out of the rack at 0400 to catch the Patriots-Raiders was brutal, but screw it. Loved seeing the snow storm - made me long for Sunday River. Oh well, next winter. Speaking of home, got to chat with Sara, Mackenzie and Delaney for 20 minutes via a video teleconference set that the ship made available to our squadron just after the New Year. Awesome to see the girls - Sara looks great, Mackenzie is getting tall, and Delaney is a crawling/cruising machine! Sara spent the entire 20 minutes managing toys, coloring books, snacks, sippie cups and Delaney's repeated escape attempts, all the while trying to conduct a conversation with yours truly. Don't worry Sara, relief is on the way; I'll be home in a few months!

As you can probably gather from all of the news reports, things are still busy on deck in Afghanistan but it's a wee bit slower right now for the air assets. In fact, the last real big push involving air power was just before Christmas up at Tora Bora, a mountainous region bordering Pakistan, just south of Kabul. As the Taliban continued to "fight this war to the death", with many of the cowards bravely throwing their hands up in the air to surrender, a few fellas made the fatal mistake of deciding to hunker down in the caves and tunnels up in that vicinity. As those cave complexes were essentially the only show in town, a majority of the air support was sent up there to get some work and get "worked", it did. I would rather have been a Derek Jeter jersey toting New York Yankees fan in the Bleachers at Fenway Park than a Taliban soldier forced to survive in those caves. After weeks of relentless air strikes, pockets of the Tora Bora started to look like the surface of the moon, a burning moon, that is - you could see the smoke billowing from 30 miles away. Secretary Rumsfeld's comment made from Bagram, comparing the fires burning up at Tora Bora to the still smoldering ruins at the WTC, were right on.

The Afghanistan countryside has come alive of late, although the word "alive" may be a little strong. Basically, the "cities" have more lights on at night, the paved roads have more traffic on them and civilians are now poking their heads out from under the covers and moving around more in the daylight. Snow dominates pretty much every peak over 5,000 feet north of central Afghanistan with the mountains surrounding Kabul reminiscent of the Sierra Nevadas this time of year. I wonder if I could get some heli-skiing in? Never mind. Land mines and deep powder are a tough mix.

The flights over Afghanistan, minus the bomb dropping part, remain the same: long transits to and from country, lengthy on station times, bookended (is that a word?) with the never-ending search for Air Force tankers in the south. Here is a standard OEF flight : launch, transit to the tanker, hold, hold, hold, hold, hold, hold, top off at a tanker, hold, hold, hold, hold some more, hit a tanker again, come home for a night trap. Our mission now is equivalent to that of a relief pitcher hanging out in the bullpen, warming up, ready to go on a moment's notice. If he gets the call, his mission is singular; deliver the beanball. It was much more fun being the starter, but such is war. You made find this hard to believe but these OEF flights I would now classify as boring; a far cry from all of the action pre-Christmas. With the recent slow down, I find myself checking my watch every 2-3 minutes to see exactly how many days we have left on deployment (more on that later). Broken glass chewing and self mutilation have surfaced as excellent hobbies to help kill the time! That said, it is extremely rewarding to fly over an area that, only 5 weeks ago, was getting pounded with laser guided bombs, and to see it now covered with USMC helicopters and US personnel brings a smile to my face. Through it all, the search continues and I hope that I get the call for one last bomb drop in Afghanistan, a bomb that drills Bin Laden right in the chest.

Had a few scary weeks during the last days of November. Was it the AAA, surface to air threat, night tanking, night traps? Nope - we almost ran out of piddle packs. For those of your who have never experienced the "cheese sandwhich", let me explain. Imagine flying for 8.5 hours - let's say from Boston to LA non-stop - on an airliner with no toilets and "movement about the cabin" is not only frowned upon, it is prohibited (you can see where I'm going here). When nature calls, the answer is the piddle pack - a small 20-ounce tough plastic bag with a ziploc top, ergonomically designed for cockpit usage, if you get my drift. Well, the word goes out late November that the ship's piddle pack inventory is running dangerously low, a timely resupply is unlikely and inflight relief generally needs to slow down, that is unless you were comfortable relieving yourself airborne on yourself.

Panic shot through the squadron and, as usual, we had some folks overreact, acting like peed-out piddle pack junkies going to any means to get their hands on some of the last remaining piddle packs: stealing, looting, begging, chicanery, hanging out in bathrooms and dark passageways looking to trade sex for piddle packs, you name it. One guy was found with TEN piddle packs in his helmet bag during the height of the Piddle Pack Depression and was beaten to within one urine drop of his life by a mob of angry pilots and RIOs, all recently forced to make an arrested carrier landing with a full bladder. Ruthless stuff. My squadron, in keeping with the theme that desperate times require desperate (i.e. moronic) measures, survived these dark days by adopting a completely unsafe personal dehydration plan coupled with the procurement of several emergency inflight relief vessels/urine storage devices - Gatorade bottles - for those times when bladder evacuation at 32,000 feet was just plain unavoidable. As an aside, donning the ever reliable DEPENDS undergarment was momentarily discussed but instantaneously dismissed. We were all in agreement that the image of a downed Navy fighter pilot in Afghanistan, paraded in front of the cameras of CNN, wearing only DIAPERS would only serve to heighten the fighting spirit and resolve of the Taliban and Al Qaida network worldwide.

This six month deployment ("referred to as a "cruise", ironically enough by the Navy) continues to slog along. Beer Day #3 is this Saturday which means that we will have been at sea for 135 consecutive days. NO ONE on the ship has ever seen a third beer day and that includes all of the salty buggers who have been doing this for 20-25 years. After the accounting collapse of Beer Day #1, the Heavies put in place a rock solid program to insure that everyone received ONLY TWO BEERS during Beer Day #2 back in November. Unfortunately, their plan worked, thus crushing my long held belief that it is virtually impossible to keep an ingenuitive American Sailor from getting just two beers on Beer Day. A challenge has been put forth for Beer Day #3 to beat the system and I think we are up for it - there is no way the Man can continue to keep us down. We are also on track to break another record this deployment , one that has been in place for 30 years. If we do not have a port call by February 21, we will break the record of 154 consecutive days at sea without a port call. It appears there are two chances of us having a port call before that date: slim and none - slim was on life support, but I believe his "plug" was pulled this morning. Doing the ENTIRE 6 month deployment without a port call is also a distinct possibility at this point which would place this deployment into the Cruise Hall of Fame: epic amounts of flight time, dropping live bombs, 4 beer days, no port calls. Don't recall seeing those last three items in the brochure at the recruiter's office. Amazingly enough, morale on the ship is still very, very high. People are still smiling, telling jokes and more importantly doing their jobs just as professional as ever. With only 8 no fly days in the last 3 1/2 months, once again, the young enlisted maintainers continue to amaze me at how hard they continue to work up there on the flight deck. Having just reread my "wanking" paragraph, let me set the record straight. Dropping live bombs on a hostile country in the defense of our nation is the culmination of many years of training (11 in my case) and a dream come true for every one of us out here, officer and enlisted alike. Loss of port calls and time away from family is a small price to pay when your country comes calling with the bill!

One last story for you. Just before Christmas, I received a large manila envelope from Ladder Company 37 (Bronx), New York Fire Department. Inside was a collection of wake cards and programs from the funerals of 14 NYC firefighters killed on September 11 as well as a note from LT John Gormley (former F-14 guy) with a special request. He wrote, "I wanted to know if you could do us a favor and spit these wake cards out of your speedbrake on one of your flights. We are real proud of these guys and we want to make sure that those greasy Taliban scumbags know exactly who they are dying for.......We know you guys are kicking ass over there and the support of your whole country is with you. Be safe and keep up the great work. We are all counting on you." The note was signed by 15 other firefighters (I will frame and hang that letter on my wall when I get home). Here it was two weeks before Christmas and I'm looking at the names and faces of 14 firemen, killed in the line of duty on the 11th. Choked up? Oh yeah.

I immediately knew exactly where I would drop these; these men were bound for Kandahar, the cultural (that word is used extremely loosely) center of the Taliban movement. On the day of the flight, I stuffed all of the cards/programs into a big envelope marked "PLEASE GIVE TO ANY TALIBAN MEMBERS" and headed up to the flight deck to coordinate getting it tucked under my speedbrake. The speedbrake is a 4 foot by 4 foot flight control surface on the aft portion of the jet that protrudes from the upper and lower surface of the fuselage. They are deployed anytime you need to slow down in a hurry (I think Maverick used them to make the bandit "fly right by" in the movie TOPGUN - sorry, forgive my cheesiness) or when landing.

The key is that they are controlled by the pilot, so anything placed beneath them will come out with the flick of a thumbswitch. Enough with the F-14 systems lecture.

Just before the Flight Deck Chief climbed up on the back of the jet to stash the envelope, he opened it to look at the contents. Looking down from the cockpit onto the flight deck, I witnessed yet another sight that I will not soon forget: 10 young enlisted men, dirty and tired, methodically looking at each of the wake cards, gazing at the faces of 14 fallen heros, many of whom were the same age of those Sailors. Judging by the looks on their faces, I would surmise that they had the same reaction that I did when I first opened the package.

Off to Kandahar. Night hop, so finding the city was easy. Lights off, just in case any Taliban AAA gunners were up late. Dropped down to an altitude lower than I probably should have but I didn't care. Rolled inverted and, while staring "downtown" Kandahar right in the face, popped open the speed brake. On December 11, 2001 at approximately 8:30 PM, Kevin Owen Reilly, CAPT William F. Burke, Jr., Durrell V. Pearsall, Jr., Michael Scott Carlo, Nicholas P. Rossomando, Peter A. Bielfield, Raymond Murphy, Hector Luis Tirado, CAPT Terry S. Halton, Archie E. Davis, Thomas J. Foley, LT John F. Ginley, Thomas G. Schoales and Michael Helmut Haub had one last flight, destination Kandahar. If things start heating up again, those names will be on bombs next time.

I want to share one more thing with all of you. One of the pieces of literature now in Kandahar was a pamphlet memorializing the life of Michael Scott Carlo. It contained family photos and a variety of essays written by his mom, dad and brother about their son/sibling and on the very last page was a photocopy of a handwritten note that was hanging over this young man's desk the day he died. Written by Mark Twain, it read: "20 years from now you will be more disappointed by the things that you didn't do then by the ones that you did. So throw off the bowlines. Sail away from the safe harbor. Catch the trade winds in your sails. Explore. Dream. Discover."

You can count on it, Michael.

Until next time, JJ

 

Late November Reports from the Army and the Navy

Commandant's Birthday Message

10 November 2001

A MESSAGE FROM THE COMMANDANT OF THE MARINE CORPS

As we commemorate the 226th anniversary of the founding of our Corps, Marines everywhere can take pride in their contributions to our great nation. We are a Corps born of an act of Congress, consecrated in sacrifice, steeped in tradition, and tested in battle. Our earned legacy is filled with the names of many great Marines: Lejeune, Vandegrift, Puller...Butler, Bestwick, Daly -- who fill the annals of our lineage with their inspired acts of vision and gallantry.

Heroic actions on the battlefield are a hallmark of our legacy. Equally compelling are the countless heroic deeds of many other Marines who exemplify the virtue of placing the needs of others above their own. Whether it be a Marine saving an Okinawan child from drowning, or pulling people from a burning wreck, or a family extending itself to provide a safe, nurturing home for disadvantaged children, our lives are indeed full of heroism. Today we celebrate these deeds, not as exploits, but as contributions to the greater good -- circumstances where Marines take care of not just their own, but reach out to care for others.

A lone Marine standing vigil on a dark night in Kosovo; a Marine Reservist serving as a firefighter or police officer who responds to an emergency in his community; a civilian Marine working alongside his counterparts in uniform who shares the perils and realities of a terrorist attack; and a committed spouse who finds the time to serve as an advocate for family programs in addition to making a home and supporting the family -- all are among the heroes of all generations. We are indebted to them for their example of strength and their presence of character. They embrace our core values and live them to the fullest. They inspire us to do the same. We admire and appreciate their example as we celebrate the birth of our Corps and our rich heritage. As our motto enjoins us, let us always be faithful, to our God, our country, our Corps and to our families. Let us also resolve to be always faithful to those Marines who have bestowed upon us our proud legacy of sacrifice, courage, and victory against any foe.

To all Marines, past and present, who uphold the finest traditions of our Eagle, Globe, and Anchor, Happy Birthday and...

Semper Fidelis,

J. L. JONES
General, U.S. Marine Corps
Commandant of the Marine Corps

Report of a Marine Corps Operation in Afghanistan

From Mike Wholley, November 27, 2001:

THE MARINES HAVE LANDED -- AGAIN

By David H. Hackworth

The first non-Special Ops unit deployed to Afghanistan is the U.S. Marines Corps -- no big surprise to this old Army doggie.

In World War II's South Pacific, Marines were "the firstus with the mostus" into the Solomons, and they led the way into Vietnam. In Korea, they landed second, but unlike the Army units initially deployed there, Gen. Edward Craig's Marine brigade hit the beach ready to fight. And without their skill, sacrifice and courage, the beleaguered Eighth Army would've been pushed into the sea during the early months of the conflict. A similar scenario occurred during the early stages of Desert Storm, in which Marine units came in ready to fight while the first Army troops -- the 82nd Airborne Division, with its insufficient anti-tank capability -- were a potential speed bump wa iting to be flattened.

The Corps, which has never lost sight that its primary mission is to fight, remains superbly trained and disciplined -- true to its time-honored slogan "We don't promise a rose garden." When, under Clinton, the Army lowered its standards to Boy Scout summer-camp level in order to increase enlistment, the Corps responded by making boot training longer and tougher. Now under USMC Commandant James Jones, that training has gotten even meaner for the young Marine wannabes waiting in line to join up, as well as for Leathernecks already serving in regular and reserve units.

Unlike U.S. Army conventional units -- their new slogan, "An Army of One," says it all -- the U.S. Marine Corps remains a highly mobile, fierce fighting team that has never forgotten: "The more sweat on the training field, the less blood on the battlefield."

The Marines are flexible, agile, ready and deadly, while the Army remains configured to fight the Soviets -- who disappeared off the Order of B attle charts a decade ago. For example, right after Sept. 11, the two Army heavy divisions in Germany -- with their 68-ton tanks that can crush almost every bridge they cross -- deployed to Poland for war games.

Hello, is there a brain at the top somewhere beneath that snazzy Black Beret being modeled at most U.S. airports by too many overweight Army National Guard troops?

The Army has eight other regular divisions, all designed to fight 20th-century wars. Three are heavy -- Tank and Mech Infantry -- and two are light, the storied 82nd Airborne and the elite 101st Airborne (now helicopter), and then there's the light/heavy 10,000-man 2nd Division that's in Korea backing up a million-man, superbly fit South Korean Army.

Less the light divisions, our Army's not versatile, deployable, swift or sustainable. The heavy units require fleets of ships and planes to move them, and it takes months to get them there -- it took Stormin' Norman six months to ready a force for Desert Storm. The 101st - - while deadly, as Desert Storm proved -- is also a slow mover requiring a huge amount of strategic lift -- ships and giant planes -- to get to the battlefield, not to mention the massive tax-dollar load to outfit and maintain it.

Sadly, today's Army is like a street fighter with brass knuckles too heavy to lift.

After the Rangers' disaster in Somalia -- where there were no tanks to break through to relieve them -- and the embarrassment of not being able to fight in the war in Serbia, Army Chief of Staff Eric Shinseki started forming light brigades strikingly similar to USMC units. When I asked, "Why the copycating?" an Army officer said: "It was either copy or go out of business. We'd become redundant because of long-term lack of boldness and imagination at the top."

The Army costs about $80 billion a year to run. It's time for Congress to do its duty and stop enjoying the benefits of all the pork this obsolescence and redundancy provides. If the Army can't change with the times -- as the powerful horse cavalry generals couldn't just prior to World War II -- then it should fold up its tents and turn the ground-fighting mission over to the Marines.

The law of nature is simple: survival of the fittest. And in the 21st century, heartbreaking as it is for me to admit, the forward-based and highly deployable U.S. Marine Corps is the fittest.

Serious Stuff:

"The following statement from Usama bin Laden and his associates purports to be a religious ruling (fatwa) requiring the killing of Americans, both civilian and military. This document is part of the evidence that links the bin Laden network to the September 11 terrorist attacks on New York and Washington. The original Arabic text of this statement may be found here."

Jihad Against Jews and Crusaders

Frontline Reports

If you have not seen "Looking for Answers", seek it out!  This web page has links to many informative articles.  The problem is much, much larger than Osama bin Laden and Al Qaeda.

For background on the Saudi Arabia situation, this is a link to the Frontline program which has links to many good reference items.

Translations from the Middle East Press

Here is a link to the website of the Middle East Media and Research Institute (MEMRI), an independent, non-profit organization providing translations of the Arab media and original analysis and research on developments in the Middle East.  It was cited by Richard Cohen, a Washington Post columnist in a recent (10/29) interesting article:

MEMRI

Before bin Laden...

Ayman al-Zawahiri - Most Wanted by FBI, Jane's Analysis, The Operations Man

From "the Dog"'

This is an interesting story, despite the fact that it comes from Hersh. Some of his more sensationalistic pieces of the past reeked of Hackworth meets Ollie Stone, but most would agree that, in this case, his comments are pretty accurate. The Saudi picture is a disturbing one, at best... a virtually brain-dead patriarch with infighting among his thousands of princes for secessionists power plays... a population increasingly being driven to poverty, strict authoritarian rule and insurrectionist fervor... a need by the royal clan to appease not only their own twisted "needs", but those of the West as well as those of the Islamic extremists, juggling runway access with terrorist cell funding... and a ready acknowledgement that their oil fields are highly vulnerable. If Saudi Arabia implodes, what follows? Egypt? The Palestinian-Israeli conflict? Another move by Saddam? The Kurds in Turkey? Pakistan? At what point does India say "Right! Fire away!" and nuke their neighbors to the northwest? At what point, under the pressure of Syria, Jordan, Egypt, the PLO, Hamas, Iraq - at what point do they elect to deposit a tactical nuke or two? What is our response to these "events"? As well, what is our plan for sunken oil tankers in the straight of Hormuz and subsequent $100 barrels of oil - during a now-certified recession? Without reading any tea leaves, it is not so difficult to see the effects of global entropy leading us rapidly down the road into full-fledged chaos theory. For some, this sounds horrifying... for me, this sounds like when the fun REALLY begins! Read on... The Dog

From the "New Yorker"

Other:

The e-mail below is from Col Nick Pratt, USMC (Ret). Col. Pratt spent a great deal of time in Afghanistan in the late 1980s. He was great Marine; he retired around 1996. He now heads up a CI school in Germany.

From: Pratt, Nick Col ®
Sent: Tuesday, September 18, 2001 4:00 AM

For terrain and weather read Les Grau's set of books: "The Bear Came over the Mountain" & "The Other Side of the Mountain." Impress upon your colleagues that once a US combatant sets foot in Afghanistan, we are the bad guy. This tradition started with a fellow named Alexander who wanted to be remembered as "the Great." We should let fellow Afghans cut up the Talibs. As the British learned and the Soviets didn't, it is easier to pay off an Afghan than to kill him. We can provide CAS, etc. I think I'd be wasting the colonel's time. He has enough to do. That said, it is your call. I'll support.

Here is what I think we should be thinking about. Share whatever you like. I sent this to some friends at HQMC who asked already. Pratt's "3 P's" strategy was part of what I told a reporter who interviewed me here on Saturday is:

Presence: No return to fortress America. We must stay engaged; economically, diplomatically and militarily.

Persistence: We must keep at this conflict through the next Congressional elections, the casualties, and etc, etc; and,

Patience: Taught to me by a great 1/9 sniper. We need to get the right kill.  Wait for the right moment and squeeze. Revenge is a dish best eaten cold.

I use "three" so my simple mind can remember it all. There are a shit pot of experts around flapping their jaws but I expect our leadership to follow a two-pronged axis:

  • First, go after known terrorists for whom we have warrants and whereabouts (Like Abu Abbas in Gaza and our buddy Imad Mugniyah in Iran). We should tell their hosts, "You are with us or against us." They get the next move and then we finish the match.

  • Next, we need to find UBL. Harder. It will take time but it will happen.

My "historic" experience has taught me a lot about the Afghan people and their neighbors. They will always resist outside intervention but they are also very pragmatic and cut deals when it is in their interest. They are the most duplicitous race on our planet. I would not be surprised if UBL's body and those of a few of his close friends don't magically appear at the mouth of the Kyber Pass with some weak explanation. The Talibs would be very wise to do this. Absent this sort of Afghan typical resolution, I anticipate that we will strike the Talibs' military capability and then let the forces of the Northern Alliance (Tajiks, ethnic Uzbeks and Shia from the Higarazat) retake the country. That will be a blood bath. Too bad Massoud is dead.

I wrote this about UBL several months ago but it is what makes him tick. As John Huston, said in Chinatown, "Politicians, ugly buildings and whores all get respectable if they last long enough." Beware, so do terrorists. It is time to put Bin Laden in perspective. Gallons of ink have probably been spilled trying to portray Osama bin Laden to a Western audience. Too much ink perhaps? Many argue thoughtfully that we have created the myth of Bin Laden though all this media attention...and they make a good argument. But while we know a great deal about this shadowy figure, no one has yet explained what makes him tick; why he has intentionally sought to become America's most wanted.

While some writers find that his early life does not fit into the stereotypical biographical or psychological profile of an international terrorist, it does resemble that of many infamous terrorists and notorious criminal figures. We need only remember "Carlos the Jackal," Venezuelan-born Ilich Ramirez Sanchez, a little rich kid who also found a thrill in murder. Born in mid-1950's of a Syrian mother and a swarthy Yemeni father, Osama bin Laden was the seventh son among fifty some odd brothers and sisters. Even though he was far down in the line of succession of his father's wealth, he was brought up in a life of heady privilege. His father had endeared him self the Saudi royal family and made a vast fortune in building their palaces. Bin Laden was rich, spoiled, sexually frustrated and bored silly.

Although he grew up in the most fundamentalist and conservative Islamic country in the world, he had a reputation of enjoying the nightlife, and the boys and girls of Beirut. Ras Beirut's coast was the real Mecca for this exasperated 'desert' youth. Hamra Street always afforded lots of alcohol, gratuitous sex, excitement and perhaps a little violence. Early on, Bin Laden appeared to be very non-confrontational, a rather mundane personality. But in 1979, the year he graduated from King Abdul-Azziz University, the Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan and his lift off a sea change. Bin Laden was enraged by the Soviet repression of the Afghans.

Like the 1967 Arab-Israeli War and the fall of Jerusalem into Israeli hands, the Soviet invasion appeared to be another in a succession of divine punishments for those straying from the path of Islam. He spent the next five years raising money and recruiting 'volunteers' to fight in the Holy Jihad against the infidel Soviets.

In 1984, he moved to Peshawar nearer the Afghan border to be closer to the action and to aid the fighters. His guesthouse, Baitul'ansar, was the first way station of "Arab" Mujahideen when they came to Afghanistan before going to the front or beginning training. He also crossed into Afghanistan to oversee the delivery of construction machinery and put it at the disposal of the Mujahideen to dig tunnels and prepared ordnance storage areas. Bin Laden started spending more and more time in Afghanistan, occasionally joining actual battles but not in an organized manner. Not content as a spectator, he wanted to organize, train and command his own fighters. He didn't wait long and created his own front to direct his own battles. His first face to face encounter with the Soviet army, using pure Arab personnel was in Paktia Province. It was a disaster.

What most Westerners do not appreciate was that real fighters, the simple, oppressed Afghan, scorned the "Internationalists," "Wahabi's" or"Arabs" as they were described in casual conversation. To gain a sense of their cynical contempt, one needs only read Les Grau's interviews with some of the Mujahideen's most successful commanders in "The Other Side of the Mountain." The Internationalists, for the most part, enjoyed posing for war pictures, video taping the "Great Game," and generally role playing. During one particularly sharp engagement on the border, they were begged to reinforce the beleaguered Afghan Mujahedin, but declined. Ask former Afghan Commander Akhtarjhan. One remarkable photograph sums up the scorn shown toward the Internationalists by the Afghans: a passing vehicle with a sign stating, "We are not Internationalists."

The relationship between the Afghans and the Internationalists was like a varsity team to the scrubs. The Afghans fought their own war and outsiders of any stripe were kept on the sidelines. The Bin Laden's of this Jihad could build and guard roads, dig ditches, and prepare fixed positions; however, this was an Afghan Jihad, fought by real Afghans, and eventually won by real Afghans. Bin Laden sat out the 'big one.'

To reconcile this profound psychological set back, Bin Laden simply started his own jihad. After Iran's former Satan (Saddam Hussain) invaded Kuwait, Bin Laden was expelled from the Kingdom in 1991 for challenging the authority of the Saudi royal family. As journalist Mary Ann Weaver noted, in bin Laden's mind "the United States had become to Saudi Arabia what the Soviet Union had been to Afghanistan: an infidel occupation force popping up a corrupt, repressive and un-Islamic government." Bin Laden was back in the jihad game. The United States was his target and he was finally center stage with no one.

Today, Bin Laden sees the evil hand of America everywhere from Serb ethnic cleansing of Bosnian Muslims to Central Asia. He is now financing and supporting groups from Algeria to the Islamic Movement of Ubekistan in Tajikistan with allegedly wild sums of money. Accurate or not, what counts to Bin Laden is that it is attributed to him and it is his jihad. He basks in an all be it dimmer limelight that was once the exclusive domain of great Afghan warriors-commanders like Ismael Khan, Haqqani, and the late Ahmad Shah Massoud. Bin Ladin reclines against a mud hut wall, his ever-ready assault rifle at his side, dressed in the "jihad chic" of the day overseeing a loose confederation of like-minded castoffs from the Muslim world, an affinity group of sorts. Planning operations and moving "khanka" (opium), he will not miss this one or play second fiddle.

A self-proclaimed terrorist, Bin Ladin told John Miller "....We do not have to differentiate between military or civilian (targets). As far as we are concerned, they are all targets, and this is what the fatwah says ...." Bin Laden missed the noble Jihad and subsequently started his own sordid little war. The Afghan Mujahideen were heroically fighting an invading army of a toleration superpower to liberate their country; Bin Laden is proudly killing innocents of democracies to liberate his ego.

Semper Fidelis,

Good luck; be lucky, be lethal. Semper Fidelis, Nick

---------

Forwarded by Nick Cominos

This reminds me of that skinny little bastard in Vietnam...could survive on a small ball of rice wrapped in blue plastic. The monsoons certainly didn't bother him and of course he knew the terrain both in the valleys and the mountains. Some things never change. And, he was one helluva fighting man. S/F, Nick Cominos

The British SAS is the Special Air Service, which is an elite fighting force (Special Forces), made up of a bunch of insane Brit's, Welsh, Irish and Scots.

SAS REPORT-In the death zone: It is one of the wildest places on earth. High in the mountain passes vehicles are useless and in winter the snow is neck deep. Then there are the Afghans, devastatingly effective guerrilla fighters, says ex-SAS man Tom Carew. And he should know - he fought alongside them against the Soviet army. Welcome to Afghanistan, a land not conquered since Alexander the Great.

Special report: Afghanistan Into Battle with the Mujahedin

Wednesday September 19, 2001
The Guardian

We were there to assess their fighting capability and to retrieve Soviet equipment. It was 1979 and the Afghans were fighting a superpower with tactics they had used against the British before the first world war. Watching them fight was like watching an old western: the cowboys would come into a valley and down would come the Indians. My task was to teach them modern guerrilla tactics. Without them, they would be exterminated. I tried to go without preconceptions, but it was hard. Before leaving Britain, everyone said be careful, they are barbaric, they'll chop you up. My boss at MI6 gave me a Flashman novel about Muslim brutality - his idea of a joke. After a few months adjusting, however, I found the Afghans to be very pleasant. We got along. I respected their bravery; they respected the way I instructed them.

I had more difficulty coping with the physical terrain. When I arrived in Peshawar, an Afghan military leader warned me, "I hope you are fit, my men march very quickly." No problem, I thought. I was used to marching. But my God; up, up, up we went. We entered the Hindu Kush mountains and started climbing. Above 3,000m the oxygen started to thin and my concentration to lapse. The Afghans were used to it, but anyone else feels really light-headed. As fighting terrain, it is an absolute nightmare. It's a natural fortress. You can't get very far with vehicles; you get bogged down and the passes are too steep. The Russians had a bloody awful time. They really got stuck. It's one thing to put in your infantry, but you've got to keep them within range of your artillery and your mortars. With bad mountain passes, this is almost impossible. None of this matters to the Afghans: they have it all organised, moving from one village to the next, where they have bases stocked with food. This is how they have fought and won wars for the past 200 years, with little bases all over the place and holes in the ground where everything is buried. This allows them to carry as little as possible and to cover ground much faster than a western force could. We didn't use tents. We lived in caves or slept rough. There were guys in the army just carrying a weapon, three magazines and some naan bread, wrapped in a shawl on their back. There is no way a western soldier could carry heavy equipment and keep up with them. For a foreign army, establishing a supply route would be very difficult. To try to carry food and water up those mountains, some of which are 4,000m high, would be madness. Because of bacteria, you have to carry bottled water and each gallon weighs 4.5kg. On some days, we were going through 11 to 15 litres. A soldier marching in those hills is going to burn between 4,000-5,000 calories a day. You need high-calorie, Arctic rations. Meat doesn't last more than a couple of days, so must be killed fresh. I contracted hepatitis from bad food.

And, of course, there is the weather. Towards the end of this month, the winter will start setting in. It begins with rain; then it freezes, then it snows. By the middle of October the snow will be very deep, up to neck height. A journey that takes three days to walk in summer will take 10 days in winter. The freezing conditions rule out helicopter support. The mist in the valleys invites crashes. The Afghan fighters know the mountains as well as a farmer from Wales knows his hills. They are like mountain goats.

I heard someone on the radio say, "Yeah, we can put in a load of four-man teams." Well, that's ridiculous. The Hindu Kush is a vast expanse of land. What can a four-man team do that you can't do with a satellite? Never mind a needle in a haystack; it's like a needle in the middle of Wembley stadium. Besides, a western task force will stick out like a sore thumb in the Hindu Kush. Most of the Afghan fighters wear sandals with old car tyre treads on the bottom. So a western boot print is instantly trackable. Once identified, the soldiers are sitting targets. We trained the Afghans in the art of "shoot and scoot"; they would lay a little ambush, let rip and disappear. They picked it up very quickly. Before long, they had learned to let the Russian convoys get half way up a pass and then blow a hole through their middle. The lucky ones died instantly. The unlucky were chopped to pieces in the aftermath. In the Hindu Kush, don't expect to appeal to the Geneva convention.

The Taliban don't have much in the way of weapons. Their best defence is their terrain. When I first arrived, all they had were old 303s, sniper rifles, and some bolt-action guns. Very few had Kalashnikovs - they weren't used to semi-automatics. Now of course, they are much more sophisticated, although their weapons maintenance is virtually zero; a lot of it won't have been upgraded since the Russian war. They might have a few Stingers left - one of the best, shoulder-held, surface-to-air missiles. But whether they're serviceable or not is debatable. They have a lot of old ZSU23s, one of Saddam Hussein's favourite weapons, which can be used in ground or air support. It's a three-barrel, 50-calibre machine gun, usually arranged in groups of two, three or four, and it's fearsome. It has a range of about 4,000m, so if you're coming in on a helicopter and have four of these blasting away at you, it's devastating. They drive their Toyota pick-ups around with these things mounted on the back. Then there are the landmines. In the early 1980s, they cleared a buffer zone between Pakistan and Afghanistan - an area equal to four days' walk - then put in observation posts on the high ground and mined it all. Everything that entered the area was obliterated and it is possible that the ground is still mined. They are small mines, the size of tennis balls, made of plastic so you can't detect them.

As for the composition of the army, most of the men were 17-24 years old. In some ways, the Afghan soldiers were no different from young guys everywhere; there was camaraderie. They might go and smoke a bit of opium, but for religious reasons, they wouldn't drink. They would get up at first light for prayers and would cover some distance before the sun came up. They would stop five times a day for prayer, although never during battle. I believe the Koran says that if you are engaged in combat, then you are excused from prayers. But they always prayed afterwards. They were normal Muslims, not fanatics. Still, in terms of their efficiency as an army, their biggest problem was the mullah influence over them. Because of the doctrine that it's a great honour to die in a holy war, they were fearless and took risks that western soldiers perhaps would not. This is not the point of a military exercise, which is to defeat the enemy and live to fight another day. If you are reckless with your life, you risk depleting the army before it has won. But it was almost impossible to raise this issue with them; it would have invited a lot of trouble. It is, in my opinion, extremely unlikely that Bin Laden is hiding in the mountains. He must have a base from where he can communicate. He can't communicate from inside the Hindu Kush. He is more likely to be on the north-west frontier of Pakistan, a heavily populated area that the west will be loath to attack. It is like the IRA tactic of hiding behind women and children; of hiding in a kids' playground. Besides, he will want to be somewhere where he can get CNN coverage of the attack on America, to admire his work.

Most of the Afghan military leaders I encountered operated from the comfort of Peshawar in Pakistan. They didn't take part in any fighting, because they wanted to be around when the fighting was over, to reap the benefits. If it comes to a ground war, I believe the western forces will have a very slim chance of victory. The last army to win in Afghanistan was that of Alexander the Great; everyone else has got mauled and pulled out. The CIA made an awful lot of maps when they were there, but a map is only as good as the person using it, and there is no safe way to get troops in.

The Afghans are a formidable enemy. I should know. We in the west pointed them in the right direction and with a little bit of training, they went a long way.

------------------------

The following was forwarded from the Assoc. of Graduates, USMA by George Proudfoot (USMC). It was written by a West Point graduate stationed in Afghanistan from 1998-1999 as part of the UN mine clearing operation.

by Richard Kidd, West Point '86

Many of you are probably not aware that I was one of the last American citizens to have spent a great deal of time in Afghanistan. I was first there in 1993 providing relief and assistance to refugees along the Tajik border and in this capacity have traveled all along the border region between the two countries. In 1998 and 1999 I was the Deputy Program Manager for the UN's mine action program in Afghanistan. This program is the largest civilian employer in the country with over 5,000 persons clearing mines and UXO. In this later capacity, I was somewhat ironically engaged in a "Holy War" as decreed by the Taliban, against the evil of landmines, and by a special proclamation of Mullah Omar, all those who might have died in this effort were considered to "martyrs" even an "infidel" like myself.

The mine action program is the most respected relief effort in the country and because of this I had the opportunity to travel extensively, without too much interference or restriction. I still have extensive contacts in the area and among the Afghan community and read a great deal on the subject. I had wanted to write earlier and share some of my perspectives, but quite frankly I have been a bit too popular in DC this past week and have not had time. Dr. Tony Kern's comments were excellent and I would like to use them as a basis for sharing some observations.

First, he is absolutely correct. This war is about will, resolve and character. I want to touch on that later, but first I want to share some comments about our "enemy."

Our enemy is not the people of Afghanistan. The country is devastated beyond what most of us can imagine. The vast majority of the people live day-to-day, hand to mouth in abject conditions of poverty, misery and deprivation. Less than 30% of the men are literate, the women even less. The country is exhausted, and desperately wants something like peace. They know very little of the world at large, and have no access to information or knowledge that would counter what they are being told by the Taliban. They have nothing left, nothing that is except for their pride.

Who is our enemy? Well, our enemy is a group of non-Afghans, often referred to by the Afghans as "Arabs" and a fanatical group of religious leaders and their military cohort, the Taliban. The non-Afghan contingent came from all over the Islamic world to fight in the war against the Russians. Many came using a covert network created with assistance by our own government. OBL (as Osama bin Laden was referred to by us in the country at the time) restored this network to bring in more fighters, this time to support the Taliban in their civil war against the former Mujehdeen. Over time this military support along with financial support has allowed OBL and his "Arabs" to co-opt significant government activities and leaders. OBL is the "inspector general" of Taliban armed forces, his bodyguards protect senior Talib leaders and he has built a system of deep bunkers for the Taliban, which were designed to withstand cruise missile strikes (uhm, where did he learn to do that?). His forces basically rule the southern city of Kandahar. This high-profile presence of OBL and his "Arabs" has, in the last 2 years or so, started to generate a great deal of resentment on the part of the local Afghans. At the same time the legitimacy of the Taliban regime has started to decrease as it has failed to end the war, as local humanitarian conditions have worsened and as "cultural" restrictions have become even harsher. It is my assessment that most Afghans no longer support the Taliban. Indeed the Taliban have recently had a very difficult time getting recruits for their forces and have had to rely more and more on non-Afghans, either from Pushtun tribes in Pakistan or from OBL. OBL and the Taliban, absent any US action were probably on their way to sharing the same fate that all other outsiders and outside doctrines have experienced in Afghanistan-defeat and dismemberment. During the Afghan war with the Soviets much attention was paid to the martial prowess of the Afghans. We were all at West Point at the time and most of us had high-minded idealistic thoughts about how we would all want to go help the brave "freedom fighters" in their struggle against the Soviets. Those concepts were naive to the extreme.

The Afghans, while never conquered as a nation, are not invincible in battle. A "good" Afghan battle is one that makes a lot of noise and light. Basic military skills are rudimentary and clouded by cultural constraints that no matter what, a warrior should never lose his honor. Indeed, firing from the prone is considered distasteful (but still done). Traditionally, the Afghan order of battle is very feudal in nature, with fighters owing allegiance to a "commander" and this person owing allegiance upwards and so on and so on. Often such allegiance is secured by payment. And while the Taliban forces have changed this somewhat, many of the units in the Taliban army are there because they are being paid to be there. All such groups have very strong loyalties along ethnic and tribal lines. Again, the concept of having a place of "honor" and "respect" is of paramount importance and blood feuds between families and tribes can last for generations over a perceived or actual slight. That is one reason why there were 7 groups of Mujehdeen fighting the Russians. It is a very difficult task to form and keep united a large bunch of Afghans into a military formation. The "real" stories that have come out of the war against the Soviets are very enlightening and a lot different from our fantastic visions as cadets. When the first batch of Stingers came in and were given to one Mujehdeen group, another group - supposedly on the same side - attacked the first group and stole the Stingers, not so much because they wanted to use them, but because having them was a matter of prestige. Many larger coordinated attacks that advisers tried to conduct failed when all the various Afghan fighting groups would give up their assigned tasks (such as blocking or over watch) and instead would join the assault group in order to seek glory. In comparison to Vietnam, the intensity of combat and the rate of fatalities were lower for all involved.

As you can tell from above, it is my assessment that these guys are not THAT good in a purely military sense and the "Arabs" probably even less so than the Afghans. So why is it that they have never been conquered? It goes back to Dr. Kern's point about will. During their history the only events that have managed to form any semblance of unity among the Afghans, is the desire to fight foreign invaders. And in doing this the Afghans have been fanatical. The Afghans' greatest military strength is the ability to endure hardships that would, in all probability, kill most Americans and enervate the resolve of all but the most elite military units. The physical difficulties of fighting in Afghanistan, the terrain, the weather and the harshness are all weapons that our enemies will use to their advantage and use well. (NOTE: For you military planner types and armchair generals - around November 1st most road movement is impossible, in part because all the roads used by the Russians have been destroyed and air movement will be problematic at best). Also, those fighting us are not afraid to fight. OBL and others do not think the US has the will or the stomach for a fight. Indeed after the absolutely inane missile strikes of 1998, the overwhelming consensus was that we were cowards, who would not risk one life in face to face combat. Rather than demonstrating our might and acting as a deterrent, that action and others of the not so recent past, have reinforced the perception that the US does not have any "will" and that were are morally and spiritually corrupt.

Our challenge is to play to the weaknesses of our enemy, notably their propensity for internal struggles, the distrust between the extremists/Arabs and the majority of Afghans, their limited ability to fight coordinated battles and their lack of external support. More importantly though is that we have to take steps not to play to their strengths, which would be to unite the entire population against us by increasing their suffering or killing innocents, to get bogged down trying to hold terrain, or to get into a battle of attrition chasing up and down mountain valleys. I have been asked how I would fight the war. This is a big question and well beyond my pay grade or expertise. And while I do not want to second guess current plans or start an academic debate I would share the following from what I know about Afghanistan and the Afghans.

First, I would give the Northern Alliance a big wad of cash so that they can buy off a chunk of the Taliban army before winter.

Second, also with this cash I would pay some guys to kill some of the Taliban leadership making it look like an inside job to spread distrust and build on existing discord.

Third, I would support the Northern Alliance with military assets, but not take it over or adopt so high a profile as to undermine its legitimacy in the eyes of most Afghans.

Fourth would be to give massive amounts of humanitarian aid and assistance to the Afghans in Pakistan in order to demonstrate our goodwill and to give these guys a reason to live rather than the choice between dying of starvation or dying fighting the "infidel."

Fifth, start a series of public works projects in areas of the country not under Taliban control (these are much more than the press reports) again to demonstrate goodwill and that improvements come with peace.

Sixth, I would consider vary carefully putting any female service members into Afghanistan proper-sorry to the females of our class but within that culture a man who allows a women to fight for him has zero respect, and we will need respect to gain the cooperation of Afghan allies. No Afghan will work with a man who fights with women.

I would hold off from doing anything too dramatic in the near term, keeping a low level of covert action and pressure up over the winter, allowing this pressure to force open the fissions around the Taliban that were already developing. I expect that they will quickly turn on themselves and on OBL. We can pick up the pieces next summer, or the summer after. When we do "pick-up" the pieces I would make sure that we do so on the ground, "man to man." While I would never want to advocate American causalities, it is essential that we communicate to OBL and all others watching that we can and will "engage and destroy the enemy in close combat."

As mentioned above, we should not try to gain or hold terrain, but Infantry operations against the enemy are essential. There can be no excuses after the defeat or lingering doubts in the minds of our enemies regarding American resolve and nothing, nothing will communicate this except for ground combat. And once this is all over, unlike in 1989 the US must provide continued long-term economic assistance to rebuild the country.

While I have written too much already, I think it is also important to share a few things on the subject of brutality. Our opponents will not abide by the Geneva conventions. There will be no prisoners unless there is a chance that they can be ransomed or made part of a local prisoner exchange. During the war with the Soviets, videotapes were made of communist prisoners having their throats slit. Indeed, there did exist a "trade" in prisoners so that souvenir videos could be made by outsiders to take home with them. This practice has spread to the Philippines, Bosnia and Chechnya were similar videos are being made today and can be found on the web for those so inclined. We can expect our soldiers to be treated the same way.

Sometime during this war I expect that we will see videos of US prisoners having their heads cut off. Our enemies will do this not only to demonstrate their "strength" to their followers, but also to cause us to overreact, to seek wholesale revenge against civilian populations and to turn this into the world wide religious war that they desperately want. This will be a test of our will and of our character. (For further collaboration of this type of activity please read Kipling).

This will not be a pretty war; it will be a war of wills, of resolve and somewhat conversely of compassion and of a character. Towards our enemies, we must show a level of ruthlessness that has not been part of our military character for a long time. But to those who are not our enemies we must show a level of compassion probably unheard of during war. We should do this not for humanitarian reasons, even though there are many, but for shrewd military logic. For anyone who is still reading this way to long note, thanks for your patience. I will try to answer any questions that may arise in a more concise manner.

Thanks, Richard Kidd

Early Reports, September 2001:

Forwarded by John Sullivan, source unknown

World Trade Center & Iwo Flag Raising

Message from the Commandant of the Marine Corps:

RTAUZYUW RUEACMC3162 2552300-UUUU--RUHEMBE RUHEMDQ RUHEMBM. ZNR UUUUU

R 122300Z SEP 01 PSN 746504E26

FM CMC WASHINGTON DC//CMC//

TO ALMAR

BT UNCLAS file://N02300//

ALMAR 041/01

MSGID/GENADMIN/CMC WASHINGTON DC//

SUBJ/A NEW REALITY//RMKS/

1. THE RECENT TERRORIST ATTACKS ON OUR NATION HIGHLIGHT THE NEW REALITY OF WARFARE. THE VERY VISIBLE ATTACKS AGAINST ICONS OF OUR DEMOCRATIC NATION AND OUR CITIZENS NO LONGER REPRESENT A SIMPLE VIOLATION OF INTERNATIONAL LAW. AS WAS EVIDENCED SO GRAPHICALLY BOTH IN NEW YORK CITY AND WASHINGTON, A NEW FORM OF OPEN WARFARE WAS DECLARED AGAINST AMERICA, DIRECTLY TARGETING CIVILIAN AND MILITARY PERSONNEL AND OUR INSTITUTIONS ALIKE. OUR COMMANDER IN CHIEF HAS STATED WE WILL RESPOND TO THIS ACT OF WAR, AND WE WILL PREVAIL. AS WE RESPOND TO THIS TRAGEDY, OUR FOCUS, AS ALWAYS, IS TO MISSION FIRST AND PEOPLE ALWAYS. IN LINE WITH THIS COMMITMENT, I WOULD LIKE TO OFFER MY CONDOLENCES TO THOSE WHO HAVE SUFFERED THE LOSS OF LOVED ONES. I WOULD LIKE TO VOICE SPECIAL THOUGHTS AND PRAYERS FOR OUR COMRADES-IN-ARMS IN THE ARMY AND NAVY WHO APPEAR TO HAVE BORNE THE BRUNT OF THE ATTACK AT THE PENTAGON. WHILE THE PROCESS OF ACCOUNTING FOR ALL PERSONNEL, ACTIVE DUTY, RESERVE, VETERAN, AND CIVILIAN IS NOT YET COMPLETE, OUR CORPS APPEARS, THUS FAR, TO HAVE BEEN SPARED ANY LOSS OF LIFE IN WASHINGTON. I AM NOT AS OPTIMISTIC WITH RESPECT TO THE ATTACK IN NEW YORK CITY. SCORES OF EMERGENCY RESPONSE PERSONNEL AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC ARE BOUND TO BE MEMBERS OF THE "MARINE FAMILY."

2. THE VERY PUBLIC DISPLAY OF THIS NEW FORM OF WARFARE COMES AS NO SURPRISE TO MARINES. OUR FOCUS ON DEVELOPING ANTI-TERRORISM AND FORCE PROTECTION (AT/FP) CAPABILITIES ACROSS OUR FORCE CONTINUES OUR TRADITION OF INNOVATION AND TRANSFORMATION. THE THREATS WE SO VISIBLY FACED HAVE FULLY VALIDATED THE REORGANIZATIONS WE HAVE UNDERGONE IN THE PAST FEW YEARS, ESPECIALLY IN THE MARINE CORPS SECURITY FORCE BATTALION AND OUR FLEET ANTI-TERRORIST SECURITY TEAM CAPABILITIES. OUR MORE RECENT EFFORTS TO INCORPORATE AT/FP SKILL SETS IN ALL DEPLOYING MARINE CORPS UNITS HAS PROVEN PRESCIENT IN ADDRESSING THE LATEST THREAT TO OUR NATIONAL SECURITY. WHILE OUR EXPEDITIONARY CULTURE REMAINS THE CENTERPIECE OF OUR WARFIGHTING CAPABILITY, THE ADDED ABILITY TO EFFECTIVELY DEAL WITH TERRORISM IS CRITICAL TODAY AND WILL REMAIN ONE OF OUR CORE CAPABILITIES FOR THE FORESEEABLE FUTURE.

3. OUR EXPEDITIONARY CULTURE HAS ONCE AGAIN PROVEN VALUABLE TO OUR NATION AND WE ARE POISED TO RESPOND TO THE ONGOING DISASTER RELIEF OPERATIONS IN NEW YORK CITY. IN CONJUNCTION WITH THE NAVY, WE HAVE ONCE AGAIN DEMONSTRATED THE VALUE OF THE NAVY-MARINE CORPS TEAM IN RESPONDING ACROSS THE FULL SPECTRUM OF CAPABILITIES THAT OUR NATION DEMANDS. IN LINE WITH THE SPECIAL BOND BETWEEN SAILORS AND MARINES, I HAVE OFFERED THE FULL COMMITMENT OF MARINE CORPS CAPABILITIES IN SUPPORT OF ANY NAVAL MISSION, ASHORE OR AFLOAT. COMMANDERS ARE DIRECTED TO REINFORCE THIS COMMITMENT BY SEEKING OUT THEIR NAVY COUNTERPARTS AND REINFORCING THIS OFFER OF ASSISTANCE WHEREVER IT MAY BE NEEDED. WHILE THIS SUPPORT INCLUDES THE FULL RANGE OF OUR CAPABILITIES, YOUR FOCUS SHOULD REMAIN ON OUR ABILITY TO SUPPORT THE AT/FP CAPABILITIES WE CAN PROVIDE.

4. WHILE WE HAVE PREVIOUSLY DISCUSSED IN DEPTH THE POTENTIAL FOR ASYMMETRIC ATTACK, WE HAVE, THROUGH THE MYRIAD ACTIONS AND REACTIONS THAT TRANSPIRED ON 11 SEP 01, EXPERIENCED THIS PARADIGM SHIFT IN A MOST PERSONAL FASHION. IN ORDER TO CONTINUE OUR TRADITION OF INNOVATION WE MUST CAPTURE THE LESSONS WE HAVE LEARNED REGARDING THIS EMERGENT FORM OF WARFARE. COMMANDERS ARE DIRECTED TO COMPILE APPROPRIATE ISSUES AND THEIR POTENTIAL IMPACT FOR THE FUTURE, AND SUBMIT THEM THROUGH THEIR ADVOCATES FOR INCORPORATION INTO THE MARINE CORPS EXPEDITIONARY FORCE DEVELOPMENT SYSTEM. REALITY IS THAT WHAT WE HAVE FACED IN THE PAST 24 HOURS IS NOT A SINGLE, ISOLATED EVENT. YESTERDAY'S ATTACK IS THE MOST VISIBLE MANIFESTATION OF A WAR FOR WHICH WE HAVE PREPARED THROUGH ORGANIZATIONAL CHANGE, AND FOR WHICH OUR EXPEDITIONARY CAPABILITIES WILL BE HIGHLIGHTED AND IN GREAT DEMAND.

5. THE MANNER IN WHICH WE REACT OVER THE DAYS AND MONTHS AHEAD WILL ONCE AGAIN HIGHLIGHT OUR READINESS AND ADAPTABILITY TO MEET THE NATION'S NEEDS ACROSS THE SPECTRUM OF OPERATIONS. IT WILL ALSO VISIBLY REINFORCE THAT WE ARE ALWAYS READY AND ALWAYS FAITHFUL.

SEMPER FIDELIS,

J.L. JONES, GENERAL, US MARINE CORPS, COMMANDANT//

BT #3162 NNNN

Reports from the Pentagon

Gentlemen and all who have worn the eagle, globe and anchor - Yesterday at the Pentagon, one of today's generation of the proud and the few showed all of us the true meaning of "Semper Fidelis".  Jim

A corporal from 8th & I standing guard duty at the Pentagon Tuesday morning was close to the point of impact of the jetliner that crashed into the building, his uniform on fire, he peeled off his clothes and in his skivies rushed into the hell to rescue victims of the disaster along with one of his Marine buddies.

Trying to pull a lady from the rubble, something fell upon his hands and broke his fingers. He continued his desperate work until his buddy grabbed him by the shoulders to restrain and get him medical help. When his fellow Marine touched his shoulders and arms, the skin came off the corporal into his friend's hands.

I wanted to give you his name and address at Bethesda Naval Hospital, but his sister said that he was not ready to receive cards and letters. He is angry. He wants to be a warrior and already knows that his career in the Corps is over. 3rd degree burns over his upper body and numerous wounds from flying debris have pretty well decided that. As soon as he is stabilized, he will be sent to the Air Force burn center in Texas. God bless our young men who wear and honor our uniform.

-------

Report from the Pentagon (forwarded by John Wegl, who wrote, "Peter Murphy is the General Counsel for the USMC. This is a first hand account from the attorney whose office was next to Peter's. I believe this is the flag they showed on the news being presented to the ACMC."):

"I am very pleased to be able to write you these lines. I know you are all anxious for information. First and foremost, I am happy to report that our people were all able to get out. It was a VERY near thing. We will be operating out of the Annex for a while; I'll fill you in as I get contact information. Please send to my HQMC account and copy this account in the near term. Many of you have asked for information about our experience; I will risk the inaccuracies of a memory fueled by terror and briefly share these bullets.

Maj Baker and Peter were meeting in Peter's ofc; I was in and out watching news reports of the attack on the WTC. After the second plane attacked, I had Cpl G check on the security status of the PNT. He reported back that it was "threatcon normal." He and I discussed the bldg's vulnerability, and the fact that it was increased since all eyes were glued to TV, and all thoughts were on NYC. I went to discuss the situation with Peter. The explosion occurred as I got to his door.

We were thrown into the air; the floor buckled and separated along the expansion joint that separated Peter's ofc from mine; the ceiling began to fall in; the lights came down. We could see the fireball rolling up past the windows. We all made for the door but it was stuck shut. Cpl G wrenched it open. When we got into the hallway it was already filling with smoke. We met Kath A. in the hall, accounting for all our people. We made toward the North end. The smoke was thicker and blacker that way, and someone came through the doorway yelling that there was fire in that end. We turned and headed south in thick smoke now, holding onto each other like blind mice. When we came to the exp. joint, we could feel the heat from the fire and see flames through the floor. We doubled back, stopped to choose which risk to take, then heard someone shouting from the North end to follow the sound of his voice, that there was a way out. We followed his voice-a young naval ofcr and my new hero, whoever he is-and made our way to the interior and on to the South parking lot. Many, many people were already helping.

You've seen to the photos of the PNT. The clean break along the left side of the gaping hole marks the line of the expansion joint. You can see directly into Peter's ofc. My office is on the ground along with Maj Lyon's. I think we all left feeling shaken but extraordinarily lucky. I recommend you all go home, hold your loved ones close, and say a prayer for those who will never get a chance to do so again."


From Hays Parks:

"Thanks for your e-mail, Clark. I was unable to reply until now because our server was destroyed in the attack. Comm was restored late last Friday.

I'm okay. From 1979 to 1998, my office was in 2D443 - the point of impact of the airliner. We moved to Rosslyn (half mile away) in 1998 as the Pentagon renovation project began. Ironically in striking the area where renovation had just been completed, casualties within the building were substantially less. Some office spaces were unoccupied, while that part had gone through 'hardening' as a result of the lessons learned from other terrorist attacks. Unfortunately, my secretary's husband was among those killed in the attack.

I'm passing this on to Bob, so that he can work his magic and pass it on to others. The messages I received from TBS classmates and other colleagues around the world -- more than fifty telephone messages and over three hundred e-mails -- are simply too many for me to answer each and every one, as much as I would like to.

It's payback time.

Semper fi,

Hays"

----

Federal Register: September 18, 2001 (Volume 66, Number 181)

Presidential Documents Page 48199

Proclamation 7463 of September 14, 2001

Declaration of National Emergency by Reason of Certain Terrorist Attacks

By the President of the United States of America

A Proclamation

A national emergency exists by reason of the terrorist attacks at the World Trade Center, New York, New York, and the Pentagon, and the continuing and immediate threat of further attacks on the United States.

NOW, THEREFORE, I, GEORGE W. BUSH, President of the United States of America, by virtue of the authority vested in me as President by the Constitution and the laws of the United States, I hereby declare that the national emergency has existed since September 11, 2001, and, pursuant to the National Emergencies Act (50 U.S.C. 1601 et seq.), I intend to utilize the following statutes: sections 123, 123a, 527, 2201(c), 12006, and 12302 of title 10, United States Code, and sections 331, 359, and 367 of title 14, United States Code.

This proclamation immediately shall be published in the Federal Register or disseminated through the Emergency Federal Register, and transmitted to the Congress.

This proclamation is not intended to create any right or benefit, substantive or procedural, enforceable at law by a party against the United States, its agencies, its officers, or any person.

IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand this fourteenth day of September, in the year of our Lord two thousand one, and of the Independence of the United States of America the two hundred and twenty-sixth.

[signed:] George W. Bush

[FR Doc. 01-23358 Filed 09-17-01; 8:45 am] Billing code 3195-01-P

[Page 48201]

Executive Order 13223 of September 14, 2001

Ordering the Ready Reserve of the Armed Forces To Active Duty and Delegating Certain Authorities to the Secretary of Defense and the Secretary of Transportation

By the authority vested in me as President by the Constitution and the laws of the United States of America, including the National Emergencies Act (50 U.S.C. 1601 et seq.) and section 301 of title 3, United States Code, and in furtherance of the proclamation of September 14, 2001, Declaration of National Emergency by Reason of Certain Terrorist Attacks, which declared a national emergency by reason of the terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center, New York, New York, and the Pentagon, and the continuing and immediate threat of further attacks on the United States, I hereby order as follows:

Section 1. To provide additional authority to the Department of Defense and the Department of Transportation to respond to the continuing and immediate threat of further attacks on the United States, the authority under title 10, United States Code, to order any unit, and any member of the Ready Reserve not assigned to a unit organized to serve as a unit, in the Ready Reserve to active duty for not more than 24 consecutive months, is invoked and made available, according to its terms, to the Secretary concerned, subject in the case of the Secretaries of the Army, Navy, and Air Force, to the direction of the Secretary of Defense. The term ``Secretary concerned'' is defined in section 101(a)(9) of title 10, United States Code, to mean the Secretary of the Army with respect to the Army; the Secretary of the Navy with respect to the Navy, the Marine Corps, and the Coast Guard when it is operating as a service in the Navy; the Secretary of the Air Force with respect to the Air Force; and the Secretary of Transportation with respect to the Coast Guard when it is not operating as a service in the Navy.

Sec. 2. To allow for the orderly administration of personnel within the armed forces, the following authorities vested in the President are hereby invoked to the full extent provided by the terms thereof: section 527 of title 10, United States Code, to suspend the operation of sections 523, 525, and 526 of that title, regarding officer and warrant officer strength and distribution; and sections 123, 123a, and 12006 of title 10, United States Code, to suspend certain laws relating to promotion, involuntary retirement, and separation of commissioned officers; end strength limitations; and Reserve component officer strength limitations.

Sec. 3. To allow for the orderly administration of personnel within the armed forces, the authorities vested in the President by sections 331, 359, and 367 of title 14, United States Code, relating to the authority to order to active duty certain officers and enlisted members of the Coast Guard and to detain enlisted members, are invoked to the full extent provided by the terms thereof.

Sec. 4. The Secretary of Defense is hereby designated and empowered, without the approval, ratification, or other action by the President, to exercise the authority vested in the President by sections 123, 123a, 527, and 12006 of title 10, United States Code, as invoked by sections 2 and 3 of this order.

Sec. 5. The Secretary of Transportation is hereby designated and empowered, without the approval, ratification, or other action by the President, to exercise the authority vested in sections 331, 359, and 367 of title 14, United States Code, when the Coast Guard is not serving as part of the Navy, as invoked by section 2 of this order, to recall any regular officer or enlisted member on the retired list to active duty and to detain any enlisted member beyond the term of his or her enlistment.

Sec. 6. The authority delegated by this order to the Secretary of Defense and the Secretary of Transportation may be redelegated and further subdelegated to civilian subordinates who are appointed to their offices by the President, by and with the advice and consent of the Senate.

Sec. 7. Based upon my determination under 10 U.S.C. 2201(c) that it is necessary to increase (subject to limits imposed by law) the number of members of the armed forces on active duty beyond the number for which funds are provided in appropriation Acts for the Department of Defense, the Secretary of Defense may provide for the cost of such additional members as an excepted expense under section 11(a) of title 41, United States Code.

Sec. 8. This order is intended only to improve the internal management of the executive branch, and is not intended to create any right or benefit, substantive or procedural, enforceable at law by a party against the United States, its agencies, its officers, or any person.

Sec. 9. This order is effective immediately and shall be promptly transmitted to the Congress and published in the Federal Register.

[signed:] George W. Bush

THE WHITE HOUSE,

September 14, 2001.

[FR Doc. 01-23359 Filed 9-17-01; 8:45 am] Billing code 3195-01-P

----

Report from San Diego

Ready or not, here we come...
Date: Mon, 17 Sep 2001 19:00:41 -0600
From: The Dog <thedog99@home.com>
To: AVR Group <avrgroup@earthlink.net>

Decided to just take a peak at the surf conditions this afternoon, as it had been months since there had been any significant swell. Imagine my surprise to find it pumping!

Snuck up on everyone, I reckon, as there was hardly anybody out! Raced home, grabbed my gear and beat feet to the bottom of the hill. The water temp is above 70, the water itself is crystal clear, a solid 4' swell is coming through... and I can hear helos coming at us like out of a scene from "Apocalypse Now"... Col. Kilgore looking for the board Lance had stolen, no doubt.

Turns out it's three Corps Snakes in form, hauling ass at about 50', headed for Pendleton. As they scream by, everyone in the lineup holds up there arms and lets out a collective whoop! Go get 'em, boys! God Bless America...

The Dog

---

We Fight Now Because We Didn't Fight Then

By Jeff Jacoby, 9/20/2001

THIS WAS George Bush's warning to the international terrorists and their sponsors:

''The United States will be firm with terrorists. We will not make concessions.... If we find states supplying money, weapons, training, identification, documents, travel, or safe haven for terrorists, we will respond. Our aim is to demonstrate to these countries that supporting terrorism is not cost-free .... We will bring terrorists to justice. We will ... identify, track, apprehend, prosecute, and punish terrorists. Terrorism is crime, and terrorists must be treated as criminals.''

That muscular vow wasn't uttered after last week's atrocities. It was made in November 1988 by then-Vice President George H. W. Bush, who put it in writing, over his signature, on the first page of the Defense Department compendium ''Terrorist Group Profiles.'' Two months later, he was sworn in as the 41st president, and if anything seemed clear, it was that he would bring to the Oval Office a cold view of terrorism and a steely commitment to fight it.

He didn't. Like Ronald Reagan before him and Bill Clinton after, Bush did little to stop international terror. The result of that failure was to convince Islamist fanatics that America was weak and gutless, and to feed the audacity that led to the most devastating terrorist attack in US history.

As vice president, Bush had seen terror's effects: He went to Beirut in October 1983, a few days after a car bomb blew up the US military barracks there, murdering 241 Marines. The Reagan administration, he said, was ''not going to let a bunch of insidious terrorist cowards shape the foreign policy of the United States.'' But that was exactly what the Reagan administration did do. Soon after the bombing, American forces quit Lebanon. And 18 years later, we have yet to ''identify, track, apprehend, prosecute, and punish'' the killers who butchered those Marines.

Or the ones who had earlier butchered 49 Americans at the US embassy in Beirut. Or the ones who hijacked TWA 847 in 1985 and killed US Navy diver Robbie Stethem. Or the ones who kidnapped CIA Officer William Buckley that same year and tortured him to death. Or the ones who hanged Marine Lieutenant Colonel William Higgins in 1989. Or the ones who seized one US citizen after another - Terry Anderson, Thomas Sutherland, Alann Steen, Frank Reed, and Joseph Cicippio, among others - and held them hostage under brutal conditions.

None of these outrages aroused the fury of the US government. Despite all the American blood on their hands, Islamic Jihad and Hezbollah were allowed to operate without hindrance, while the regimes in Damascus and Tehran that financed and sheltered them were never forced to pay a price for their hostile behavior.

Even when the United States did retaliate for terrorist attacks, its response was mild and ineffective. To avenge the destruction of Pan Am 103 and the slaughter of 259 innocents in December 1988, the United States was content to prosecute two Libyan operatives who had been involved in the bombing. More hirelings were put on trial after the first bombing of the World Trade Center in 1993. When terrorists blew up the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania, Washington lobbed a few cruise missiles at training camps in Afghanistan and a chemical plant in Sudan.

What the US government should have done was root out and destroy the terrorist groups mounting these attacks. It should have leveled economic, diplomatic, and military penalties against the dictatorial states backing them. It should have behaved like a great power enraged by the murder of its citizens. Instead it did next to nothing. And vicious men saw and drew the obvious conclusion.

That wasn't all they saw.

They saw the United States label Saddam Hussein ''worse than Hitler'' and assemble a vast army to fight him - only to stop the war when his troops were on the run, leaving him as ruthless and dangerous as ever. They saw how Saddam violated the terms of the cease-fire and resumed his quest for nuclear, biological, and chemical weapons - and how the United States drew line after line in the sand, then failed to defend any of them.

They saw Americans cut and run from Somalia because some of their soldiers were killed there. They saw Washington dither for years about how or whether to stop the bloodshed in the Balkans. They saw how easy it was for the Chinese to acquire military secrets, and how surprised Americans were when India and Pakistan went nuclear. They saw that nothing bad happened to nations on the State Department's list of terror-sponsors. They saw a government so unwilling to give offense that it scrapped the term ''rogue states'' in favor of ''states of concern.''

All this and more the vicious men saw. And they concluded that America was rich but cowardly, mighty in arms but weak in spirit, unwilling to fight for its principles or to risk its sons in battle. America, they decided, had gone soft. And so the time had come to attack.

Jeff Jacoby's e-mail address is jacoby@globe.com.

This story ran on page 19 of the Boston Globe on 9/20/2001.

© Copyright 2001 Globe Newspaper Company

Priceless...